Am I the only one who has noticed the usual major foul-up — par for the course for such incidents in India — at the Dinanagar police station, in Gurdaspur district in the terrorist attack Monday? Every police agency in sight — and the nearby army units included rushed like mad and acted like the perfect brainless dolts. If the three attackers — fidayeen fashion — were intent on killing as many people as possible and dying in the process, then obviously they succeeded. But was the gunning down of the terrorists necessary considering they were holed up in a police station, were surrounded, and had no means or avenue of escape? Wouldn’t it have been advisable, with the idea of establishing the Pakistan hand in this latest atrocity, to wait it out, engage the three killers just enough to have them expend their ammunition and whatever other ordnance (grenades) they came loaded with, and then apprehended them for interrogation to generate irrefutable evidence??? The fact that even if one member of the strike team — Kasab — was caught alive in the 26/11 Mumbai attack provided clinching proof of Pak ISI’s complicity, making it hard for Islamabad to wriggle out of the corner. With the Gurdaspur intruder-killers killed, however, no amount of GPS tracking record will do other than buttress Islamabad’s argument that this was another inside job by a homegrown team of malcontents. Once the ammo kits were exhausted it is possible the three would have killed themselves with cyanide pills, assuming they carried them to terminate a botched up operation as this certainly was, and as a last bit of suicidal action. But this would have been preferable to their being killed and the Punjab Police SWAT unit tasked with the job thereafter jumping up and down and hollering like a bunch of overgrown school boys with an adrenaline rush! It was all so laughably unprofessional! On Monday even as the action was unfolding Rajasthan Patrika asked me about it, and I said that the first order of business was to catch them alive by any and all means. That, of course, didn’t happen. After all these years of precisely this kind of mindless actions by the police and army, it is time GOI drafted Standard Operating Procedures for such situations. Every last policeman down to the local thana level in every damned locality of the country ought to be drilled in following some the simple rules of conduct and engagement aimed, in the main, at catching and preserving the perpetrators of such attacks for interrogation and generation of incriminating evidence. Boy, the Indian Police, the State Police, and the State and Central Govts seem like such a bunch of bozos who learn nothing, and never will. The subsequent piece of news from the Punjab authorities that none of the men killed were Sikhs was a little too pat for comfort. The Akali govt’s attempts to curry favour with the diehard miniscule minority of Khalistan supporters and sympathizers in order to win over their wealthy supporters safely away in California, Canada, and elsewhere in the West is reprehensible. This element too has gone uncommented upon and, so far, unprobed.
Search
Categories
- Afghanistan (180)
- Africa (68)
- arms exports (350)
- asia-Pacific/Indo-Pacific (335)
- Asian geopolitics (844)
- Australia (85)
- Bangladesh (60)
- Bhutan (61)
- Brazil (9)
- Central Asia (202)
- China (573)
- China military (508)
- civil-military relations (466)
- corruption (108)
- Culture (410)
- Cyber & Space (87)
- Decision-making (413)
- Defence Industry (402)
- Defence procurement (56)
- disarmament (81)
- domestic politics (352)
- DRDO (312)
- Europe (410)
- Geopolitics (768)
- geopolitics/geostrategy (124)
- Great Power imperatives (792)
- guerilla warfare (99)
- India's China Policy (522)
- India's Pakistan Policy (403)
- India's strategic thinking and policy (793)
- Indian Air Force (508)
- Indian Army (520)
- Indian democracy (212)
- Indian ecobomic situation (401)
- Indian Navy (437)
- Indian Ocean (283)
- Indian para-military forces (58)
- indian policy — Israel (34)
- indian policy — Israel, Iran and West Asia (135)
- Indian Politics (415)
- Indian state/administration (16)
- Indo-Pacific (77)
- Intelligence (82)
- Internal Security (241)
- Iran and West Asia (126)
- Islamic countries (35)
- Israel (53)
- Japan (144)
- Latin America (29)
- Maldives (54)
- MEA/foreign policy (346)
- Military Acquisitions (456)
- Military/military advice (346)
- Missiles (277)
- Myanmar (41)
- Nepal (28)
- nonproliferation (144)
- North Korea (40)
- Northeast Asia (146)
- NRIs (21)
- nuclear industry (73)
- Nuclear Policy & Strategy (323)
- nuclear power (59)
- Nuclear Weapons (317)
- Pakistan (453)
- Pakistan military (384)
- Pakistan nuclear forces (108)
- Relations with Russia (205)
- Russia (341)
- russian assistance (213)
- russian military (152)
- SAARC (258)
- sanctions (11)
- satellites (35)
- society (590)
- South Asia (826)
- South East Asia (206)
- space & cyber (34)
- Special Forces (102)
- Sri Lanka (60)
- Strategic Forces Command (139)
- Strategic Relations with South East Asia & Far East (220)
- Strategic Relations with the US & West (485)
- Taiwan (41)
- Technology transfer (302)
- technology, self-reliance (39)
- Terrorism (210)
- Tibet (132)
- Trade with China (14)
- UN (77)
- United States (554)
- US. (550)
- Vietnam (120)
- war & technology (5)
- Weapons (506)
- West Asia (137)
- Western militaries (208)
-
Join 4,303 other subscribers
Subscribe via RSS
Archives
- January 2023 (1)
- December 2022 (2)
- November 2022 (2)
- October 2022 (3)
- September 2022 (5)
- August 2022 (5)
- July 2022 (4)
- June 2022 (3)
- May 2022 (4)
- April 2022 (5)
- March 2022 (10)
- February 2022 (3)
- January 2022 (2)
- December 2021 (4)
- November 2021 (4)
- October 2021 (3)
- September 2021 (3)
- August 2021 (6)
- July 2021 (4)
- June 2021 (3)
- May 2021 (4)
- April 2021 (10)
- March 2021 (5)
- February 2021 (6)
- January 2021 (6)
- December 2020 (5)
- November 2020 (5)
- October 2020 (5)
- September 2020 (8)
- August 2020 (7)
- July 2020 (8)
- June 2020 (10)
- May 2020 (7)
- April 2020 (5)
- March 2020 (5)
- February 2020 (7)
- January 2020 (6)
- December 2019 (5)
- November 2019 (4)
- October 2019 (4)
- September 2019 (6)
- August 2019 (6)
- July 2019 (5)
- June 2019 (8)
- May 2019 (10)
- April 2019 (3)
- March 2019 (9)
- February 2019 (8)
- January 2019 (7)
- December 2018 (9)
- November 2018 (10)
- October 2018 (2)
- September 2018 (12)
- August 2018 (9)
- July 2018 (5)
- June 2018 (7)
- May 2018 (8)
- April 2018 (6)
- March 2018 (3)
- February 2018 (6)
- January 2018 (9)
- December 2017 (6)
- November 2017 (6)
- October 2017 (6)
- September 2017 (8)
- August 2017 (10)
- July 2017 (10)
- June 2017 (9)
- May 2017 (4)
- April 2017 (8)
- March 2017 (8)
- February 2017 (8)
- January 2017 (9)
- December 2016 (12)
- November 2016 (10)
- October 2016 (11)
- September 2016 (11)
- August 2016 (15)
- July 2016 (13)
- June 2016 (15)
- May 2016 (9)
- April 2016 (19)
- March 2016 (11)
- February 2016 (11)
- January 2016 (19)
- December 2015 (10)
- November 2015 (24)
- October 2015 (11)
- September 2015 (8)
- August 2015 (6)
- July 2015 (13)
- June 2015 (14)
- May 2015 (11)
- April 2015 (11)
- March 2015 (3)
- February 2015 (7)
- January 2015 (5)
- December 2014 (4)
- November 2014 (4)
- October 2014 (5)
- September 2014 (3)
- August 2014 (7)
- July 2014 (6)
- June 2014 (9)
- May 2014 (5)
- April 2014 (5)
- March 2014 (4)
- February 2014 (7)
- January 2014 (10)
- December 2013 (8)
- November 2013 (6)
- October 2013 (7)
- September 2013 (13)
- August 2013 (17)
- July 2013 (7)
- June 2013 (11)
- May 2013 (7)
- April 2013 (4)
- March 2013 (6)
- February 2013 (10)
- January 2013 (7)
- December 2012 (6)
- November 2012 (6)
- October 2012 (5)
- September 2012 (6)
- August 2012 (9)
- July 2012 (5)
- June 2012 (5)
- May 2012 (11)
- April 2012 (12)
- March 2012 (11)
- February 2012 (9)
- January 2012 (6)
- December 2011 (8)
- November 2011 (6)
- October 2011 (28)
- September 2011 (2)
I am someone who was born and brought in the narrow streets of that small town called Dinanagar and it hurt me when it was attacked. But that’s not the point. If they were so brain washed to have audacity to cross the boarder and get locked in a police station, they would have already presumed themselves dead. I saw their photographs, 18-20 yrs, semi literate and seemed from lower strata of their society. Their bank accounts must have been credited heavily before they left. No effort of security forces would have caught them alive. In an effort to catch them alive, there could have been more damage to us. A better way to answer ‘them’ would be different. And there are hundreds of ways of doing that, directly or indirectly.
But where was the harm’, as I argued, in waiting out these killers? At most they’d have killed themselves but, more likely, considering their lives were on the line, they’d have surrendered, and India would have secured a bonanza of evidence.
Thanks for getting the indigestible out of our mouth & minds.
Standard Operating Procedure & it being known to the last person in the hierarchy.
Funny, Not one Home Minister at any level doesn’t bother to get this basic thing done.
First Catch them alive,
If not, Allow them to die themselves
Last, Kill them
Might be, some one was in a hurry to get a promotion or update his service record.
(with apologies, for being politically incorrect) Makes me wonder, if we should take all those Sardarji jokes a bit seriously.
In my opinion what they did was right! Every terrorist attack on India is either directly or indirectly planned and funded by pakistan, no matter how many evidences or witnesses you give them they always gonna deny it. The whole process of accusing and accepting would take a year or even more to be accomplished. And after this even if you cry in front of US all they do is talking and paper signing which eventually results in nothing. I believe that only a vicious action delivers the message of intolerance in situations like these. On the other hand if you try to be diplomatic they’ll find other ways to conceal their identity and still keep attacking again and again. so I believe that India should grow into powerful country by actually acting and not just by talking.
By all means act, not talk. But act smart first!
I wholeheartedly agree with your view pt.
1. The security of our country is handled in a lackadaisical manner with turf protection being more significant than actual conduct of the operation. In this case, the Punjab Police stated that it was their operation. Sad day for all.
2. We do not even have a integrated communication system where all SF elements in one geographical area are in radio communication with each other. The police, CAPFs and army units operate different equipment.
3. We need an integrated response strategy which cuts across security forces and their controlling HQs. The rules of engagement must be laid down that in case of any such eventuality, the nearest available SF units are used instead of calling NSG or any other detachment and thus save precious time. Mumbai casualties in 2008 would have been much lesser if the army units present there were used were quickly pressed into service instead of waiting for NSG to arrive. It was a Home Ministry turf and thus lives were lost due to faulty procedures and egos.
4. The moot question however is, will the controlling Bureaucracy let such a integrated response strategy be in place??
On another note, the following news item mentions that Rafale was offered to PM Modi for $200 million per piece in his French visit. That offer had an added 20% discount which means the original offer to UPA government was $ 250 million per piece in 2014. That also means the original deal of 126+63 options = 189 X 250 million = $ 47.3 Billion. The total cost of developing Rafale aircraft was near-about the same amount so French decided to extract all of it from the Indian contract. The UPA morons and majority of the paid defence media were fooling common people that it was a $10-12 billion contract !!!! Moreover, three years earlier the fighter was offered at prices of below $100 million so in three years the price escalated to 2.5 times !!!!
Wow ! What a deal !!!
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/rafale-deal-pricing-issues-indias-insistence-on-50-local-spending-lead-to-missing-of-july-target/articleshow/48288656.cms
Dear Mr Karnad after all these years of terrorism,do we still have to prove the obvious….the paki hand….at this stage and so many years down the line if we still try to get hold of proof of paki involvment,then i think we are brain dead bozos or whatever that means…..
regards
oh by the way luv ur blogs!
Knowing the obvious, and proving it, are two very different things and it is a distinction the Indian State has difficulty understanding whence police/SF/intel SOPs not emphasizing taking cornered terrorists, to the extent possible, alive. And the Gurdaspur thugs couldn’t have been more cornered, and more at the surrounding Indians’ mercy.