BHARAT KARNAD is Distinguished Fellow at the United Service Institution of India and Emeritus Professor for National Security Studies, Centre for Policy Research, New Delhi. His most recent book, Staggering Forward: Narendra Modi and India’s Global Ambition was published by Penguin in September 2018. Previous books include Why India is Not a Great Power (Yet) (Oxford University Press, October 2015), Strategic Sellout: India-US Nuclear Deal (2009), Índia’s Nuclear Policy (Praeger, 2008), Nuclear Weapons and Indian Security: The Realist Foundations of Strategy, now in its second edition (Macmillan, 2005, 2002), and Future Imperilled: India’s Security in the 1990s and Beyond (Viking-Penguin, 1994) .
He was Member of the (First) National Security Advisory Board, Member of the Nuclear Doctrine-drafting Group, National Security Council, Government of India, and, formerly, Advisor on Defence Expenditure to the Finance Commission, India.
Educated at the University of California (B.A., Santa Barbara; M.A., Los Angeles), he has been a Visiting Scholar at Princeton University, University of Pennsylvania, and the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champagne, and Foreign Fellow at the Shanghai Institutes of International Studies and the Henry L. Stimson Centre, Washington, DC. He lectures at the top military training and discussion forums, including CORE (Combined Operational Review and Evaluation), DRDO Annual Directors’ Conference, National Defence College, Higher Command Courses at the Army War College, College of Air Warfare, College of Naval Warfare, College of Defence Management, College of Military Engineering, and at Army Command and Corps level fora and equivalent in the other two Armed Services, and Defence Services Staff College, and also at the Indian Administrative Service Academy, Foreign Service Institute, and the National Police Academy.
He was commissioned by the Headquarters, Integrated Defence Staff, Ministry of Defence, to conceptualize, conduct for several years, and lecture at the annual Strategic Nuclear Orientation Course for Brigadier-rank officers and equivalent from the three Armed Services, and conceived and conducted the first ever high-level inter-agency war game on the nuclear tripwire in the subcontinent (at the Army War College, 2003).
He is a TV commentator and writes the occasional newspaper op/ed column in Indian newspapers and a sometime contributor to various periodicals, including a column (‘Realpolitik’) in BloombergQuint.com, Seminar, Open Magazine, India Today, The Week, and web news & views outlets — The Wire.in, Rediffnews.com, thecitizen.in, The Eastern Link.
STATEMENT OF INTENT
‘Security Wise’ was the title of a fortnightly newspaper column I wrote for many years in the Asian Age and Deccan Chronicle and, later, in the New Indian Express. It is a blog dedicated unapologetically to espousing realpolitik foreign and military policies and realist approach as vehicle for furthering India’s national interest (stripped of abstract universal concerns, such as world peace, disarmament and nonproliferation, Third World good, etc., and of emphasis mainly on soft power, that have for too long been the bread and butter of Indian foreign policy, both in the declaratory sense and in substantive terms).
In a system of sovereign nation-states and a harsh “dog eat dog” international milieu, National Interest should be the only motivation and driver of all state policies in the external realm. Conjoined to the relentless and focused acquisition of strategic hard power capabilities, it will, as this analyst has argued since 1979, achieve for India Great Power it has always potentially been but which governments since 1947 have failed to realize. This is because of the absence of clearly articulated national vision, strategy, disruptive game-plan and policies, and of strong political will to implement them. It has resulted in an often skewed world-view, miscued geopolitics, a myopic approach fixating on “unfriendly neighbours”, an over-accommodating stance vis a vis powerful states, an inclination to uphold the status quo rather than challenge and upend the prevailing Asian and global order that discriminates against and victimizes India, a manifestly wonky threat perception, an institutional disregard for achieving arms self-sufficiency and, hence, a military, dependent on imported armaments, with limited reach and clout backed by a truncated nuclear deterrent (that can boast of credible and reliable thermonuclear weapons only if India resumes open-ended underground nuclear testing, which it should do at the earliest).
This constitutes the meat of the argument I have made for three and half decades now (in 2016), within government and military circles and outside of them, and reflects my bedrock beliefs, which are reflected in all my books, other writings, and in the posts to-date on this blog. The arch-realist policy compass ‘Security Wise’ represents will not change, whichever the government of whatever ideological stripe is ruling in New Delhi at any given time. This usually puts this analyst and his analysis at odds with the policies of the day and those who make them because their flawed basics don’t seem to change even when the world does.
Thank you for “Short sighted policy on china”. You know very well our Indian politicians. I accept that India is a follower not a Leader.Basically, our Long sight is main problem; whenever a problem or crisis arises we think only the short remedy not a Long-term Solution. This is different from what other countries do.
You are one of genius and can guide the people of India to go with pride of its heritage and our technical and leadership role to build a great nation like past of our vedic period. In past we have done many miracle in every spare of life. I am requesting you to change the mind set of Indian people as we act today to take challenges and reemerge as great nation again.
Well sir, I am impressed with your posts and its intent.
Sir, I run my own blog on national interest along with my friend.
We there take up an issue and analyse and present conclusions all for the sake of good if India..
If you consider it, please have some time there and read posts.
I will be happy and proud if you reply back with your valuable comments
sir, just wanted to ask you one thing. As we all know most of your audience is military audience so they already have a skill-set, which others DON’T have. Wouldn’t it be better to have some militia groups on the indian side
And please tell me sir your thoughts sir on the experiment done by ERIK PRINCE OF BLACKWATER and his concept of civilian soldiers
i was actually fascinated by it and as far as it gets the job done who cares.
But it died out because of bureaucracy in U.S.
Could it happen in india ,if the government make a militia like hezbollah or something which could be secular in nature and would be able to defend the national flag
the reason being, its one of the world’s oldest professions and why not resurrect it
Just asking for your opinion