
[Sleeping Don of Shenzen]
One of the reasons not to take summits seriously is because they are all heavily scripted, with the principals dutifully reading from texts prepared by their Foreign Offices. And, in recent years because — YAWN! — US President Donald Trump sleeps through them. If these meetings are not sleepathons than they are only photo ops. Even that didn’t quite work at the Shenzen summit billed by some optimists as Yalta 2.0. Placed from the tallest to the shortest, they looked, as a comedian joked, like a police lineup! The trilateral achieved so little the highlights were (1) the separate 2-hour bilateral between the Chinese President Xi Jinping and his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin, where they got some business done — mainly consolidating their mutually supporting policies on Iran and Ukraine, and (2) Xi’s condescendingly patting Trump on his back after the latter talked, in effect, about leaving Taiwan to manage its security on its own the best it can!
The comparison, in any case, is insulting to the original Conference held on February 4-11, 1945, of the “Big Three” warlords — US President Franklin Roosevelt, Soviet dictator Stalin and the British Prime Minister Winston Churchill in Yalta, a resort town on the Crimean coast. It was called in the aftermath of the Allied victory in Europe in the Second World War essentially to territorially divide up the spoils. (Allied victory in Asia followed 6 months later, incidentally, after Japan announced its surrender on August 15.)
Aware that Stalin could not be stopped, not after the Red Army had, in the main, destroyed the German war machine, Churchill as the reprentative of Europe at that Meet agreed on the Soviet Union carving out a very wide buffer zone that Stalin insisted on. Other than the Baltic states annexed in 1940, all of Eastern Europe from Poland, East Germany to Romania, and the Balkan states were pushed into Moscow’s bloc — which later constituted the Warsaw Pact set up to rival the US-led NATO. The wheelchair bound Roosevelt (who died two months later) didn’t much care how Europe was divvied up and, like Churchill, was not eager to resist Stalin. The result was an extraordinary outcome — the Cold War that decided the future of the world for the rest of the 20th Century.
Now, fast forward to Shenzen — “Yalta 2.0”. WHAT?! Here are the 3 supposedly “great powers” of today seeking to rule the world — a recessive and faltering US, a flailing Russia that cannot overcome an Ukraine abandoned by Trump, and a resource-rich China that is unhinged by the mere thought of a militarised Japan, and cannot even intimidate Taiwan, which it claims as its own! These are not powers that can reorder and run the international system and G3, like G2, is fated to remain a lable never to emerge as an actual power configuration. 2026 is not 1945, and even a weak state, Iran, and a rebel group, the Houthis, are militarily driving America, ostensibly the most powerful of the “Three Amigos”, into the ground.
——–

[Modi at the Pravasi Bhartiya Diwas convention, 2023]
Come winter, and it is time for some of the Indian diasporic birds to fly home for the annual Pravasi Bhartiya Diwas celebrations (next year’s edition scheduled in Kolkata, January 7-9, 2027). It is one of the two public events — the other being “Raisina Dialogue”, that preoccupies most officers in the MEA for most of the year!
The other day, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar announced its theme: “Return to Roots: Reigniting the diaspora connect with Bharat” before airing the Narendra Modi government’s view that the 37 million-strong community of Non-Resident Indians are “increasingly important” to realising the Prime Minister’s vision of “Viksit Bharat” by 2047 owing principally, he said, to “Their knowledge, expertise, entrepreneuirial spirit and technology capabilities, and also their global networks” which when mobilised, “will contribute to India’s growth and to India’s development equally.”
Strangely, the pravasis who actually make an impact, the mostly unskilled labour force in the Gulf, are no part of this celebration, nor will their representatives, assuming there are any, get to shake hands with the Prime Minister. But it is their hard-earned dinar remittances from the extended Gulf region that help the Finance Ministry to balance the budget and to keep India’s head above water! Last year, the inflow reached $150.71 billion, accounting for a fifth of the total international remittances of some $728.6 billion, making India the biggest recipient among low and middle income countries.
Not only is this fact of an NRI economic lifeline not highlighted, there is little acknowledgement of the millions sweating blood, working uncomplainingly in difficult jobs under a desert sun in the construction and service sectors, living frugally in crowded “hostels”, just so their meagre savings can be sent home which, cumultatively, end up as hundreds of billions of dollars that enables the Indian republic to survive. But there are a lot of sullen Indian diplomats posted in that region who’d rather not be bothered to serve this “riff-raff”. Still, the remittances by this “riff-raff” raise the standard of living of their families in villages, and spur consumption and the local economies, Moreover, because the Gulf states entertain no ideas of giving foreigners citizenship rights, these workers have no illusion other than to maximise their earnings, just so they can return home and live in some comfort. The transformation of the Kerala countryside is a testament to this phenomenon. This is real gainful change for India!
Sure, some of the incoming $150 billion is remitted by the upper middle class NRIs — engineers, scientists, doctors, academics, managers in Financial Institution — the white collar type and the like — MEA’s pravasi poster boys (and girls)! The more prosperous among them buy into New York and European hedge funds that exploit the differential in interest rates and invest in the Indian stockmarket just to turn a quick profit. This is not illegal but it is “hot money”. Per Indian Economic Service data the Cumulative Foreign Portfolio Investment (FPI) in the country reached $263.85 billion in August 2026. But there’s no breakdown of this figure by the Securities and Exchange Board of India to reveal the proportion attributable to hedge funds. Market savvy types speculate that it may be 20%-30% of the incoming funds. This amounts to a tidy quantum of foreign exchange. The point to make is that rich Indians investing in Western hedge funds investing in India do not do it to benefit India!
The other, “educated”, lot — engineers, scientists, doctors, academics, and financial managers from the vast Middle Class, head to the West, supposedly for “higher education”, but with the sole purpose of settling down in the US, Canada, UK, Australia, and western Europe by any and all possible means. The less capable take the “dunkey” route and increasingly find the doors to the Western world closing on them. Even the IT types are discovering that, with the H1B visa regime in its sunset phase, their future is pretty bleak. The mostly English-speaking countries, the favoured destinations for migration, these days happily admit foreign students into their universities, extract hefty fees for years, hand them degrees, before the host state asks them to get the hell out!
All these states are now implementing or introducing measures to dim the chances of converting student visas and local degrees into domicile status. The desperate diplomatic efforts by Modi, Jaishankar and Company to bolster their middle class support over the past decade-plus to keep the work-visa doors open for Indian talent, have failed. Because even though Delhi is never met with a No, social and political pressures to restrict immigration from the Third World have led to new rules and stricter application of old ones that achieve much the same thing. India is front and centre on the target list because more Indian youth, unfortunately, want to get out, and stay out, because trying to earn a livelihood here is hard, and the Indian state, over the years, hasn’t made it easier.
The MEA, however, is happier to engage the more insidious among the emerging breed of NRIs in the policy sector — think tanks, media, business and universities, who seek visibility by criticising Indian policies from the point of view of not being aligned with the US interests, and to influence them through Indian print and electronic media which afford them platforms to propagate their views, thereby supporting the work of the Delhi branches of American thinktanks — Brookings, Carnegie, the Aspen Institute. Their intention usually is to use these forums to improve their professional prospects back in the US (or where ever), hoping that their vocal denunciations of the Indian state and its policies, and of the deficiencies in its democratic functioning, will be noticed, and rewarded with ‘plum book’ (political) appointments in friendly Administrations in Washington. It has worked for many US-based NRIs.
The other lot that frequents the pravasi diwas celebrations is more modest in its aims. In this category are hordes of office holders of innumerable “Indian associations” in foreign lands — reflecting the diversity of caste, sub-caste, religious, provincial differences in India. They treat their yatra as a photo op, with pics featuring them with the PM or Jaishankar, to take back to impress other Indians with their “connections” in the Indian government, and as a means to cadge invitations from Indian embassies and consulates for their events — a fairly harmless activity.
If the connection of NRIs settled down comfortably in the West, who have made their choice of where to live and to build their future, stops at the Pravasi Diwas, there’d be nothing to worry about. But, while there has long been a push here and there, there is now seemingly a serious campaign afoot to get NRIs in the US and western Europe, in particular, “dual citizenship” and voting rights in India. There’s not only Jaishankar singing their praises, but the suavely persuasive Shashi Tharoor, MP from Kerala, erstwhile Minister of State, MEA, and still earlier, head of Public Relations at the United Nations, who took a shot at heading the organisation, sort of heading it.
He makes an unconvincing case for it though in his Indian Express column of November 12. Curiously, he builds his case on the basis of various stars and starlets in Bollywood, which he equates with “globalised Indian society”, and who, he states, “carry foreign passports while working, living and identifying as Indians.” Claiming that these “prominent” actors “loom large in the Indian national consciousness… and yet,” he complains, “their legal rights remain bound to the visas in their passports.” Not sure how looming large in a country’s consciousness entitles foreigners to its passport!
“Where does one draw the line”, Tharoor asks plaintively, “when dealing with people who are, in every practical and emotional respect, Indian” and for whom “retaining or acquiring a foreign passport is a functional decision aimed at facilitating global mobility, avoiding cumbersome visa procedures, or securing family obligations, rather than a rejection of their primary cultural identity”? Certainly, an US passport is a convenience, but increasing the convenience of NRIs may not be the best reason to accord them Indian citizenship rights! Affording such rights, inclusive of the right to vote in Indian elections, Tharoor affirms, somewhat questionably, “would add to the rich national treasury of human resources we can call upon…to contribute who would”, he ends with Macaulayesque flourish, “be Indian in blood, culture, taste, and finally, again, in nationality.”
It is hard to ignore Tharoor’s slant. He speaks for the privileged among the 37 million NRIs living abroad, for those who have made it in the West. With the social situation worsening in their new countries, many of them are looking for a bolthole in the land of their origin just in case things turn bad, and for the venturesome among them a chance to set up Indian extensions of companies they have founded, to avail of tax and other concessions, and to repatriate profits!
India being Third World — what is important is not “know-how”, it is “know who”, and the Pravasi Diwas and similar events help well-placed West-based NRIs to connect with the pooh-bahs in the Indian government who, despite all the talk by Modi and his Finance Minister about next-gen economic and administrative reforms, still wield the whip hand where commercial and industrial deals are concerned (because land acquisition and labour laws remain unreformed).
The nation can and should expect nothing from these self-serving welloff NRIs. India owes them nothing. The poor Indian taxpayer has already subsidised their education in IITs, IIMs, IISc, et al, and, by the choices they made, set them up to contribute to the security and wellbeing of the US and the European states they live in! They chose after securing advanced degrees abroad to settle down there, not for “functional” reasons as Tharoor says, but for substantive reasons and they make no bones about it, or about their new national loyalties. It is evidenced in how feverishly they plug the American line on foreign policy, nonproliferation, technology transfer, etc, and are more stridently American than Americans!
The NRIs are unlike the Chinese in the US, for instance, who routinely help China acquire sophisticated US military tech and to scout the American scene for it. And, it is best to remember, that when the Sundar Pichai’s and the Satya Nadella’s of the US corporate world come calling, they do so to further the interests of Google and Microsoft. To treat them as benefactors is like thanking the hangman for the noose! Talking of Jaishankar’s reference to NRIs’ “expertise” and “technology capabilities”, isn’t it revealing that there has not been a single patriotic “AQ Khan”-type among the hundreds of thousands of NRIs who work and have worked in sensitive positions in NASA, in defence industrial firms like Lockheed, Boeing, in innumerable R&D labs, and in the US government, and in Europe, who has spirited away a single sensitive document or even the meanest tech for India’s benefit?
Further, to accord all 37 million NRIs voting rights in state and general elections in India is to open up the country to unstoppable foreign manipulation from the inside. As it is, it has been easy for the US Central Intelligence Agency to recruit Indians high up in the political and bureaucratic ranks. To now allow NRIs — potential intel assets for the US and Europe to set up residence in India with all the rights, is to invite internal subversion on an industrial scale, what with the likelihood of their linking up with the army of easily compromisable babus, top to bottom, within the establishment, willing to do their bidding for a consideration. At the political level, we have already experienced how that can turn out.
The Sikh underworld in Canada engaged in extortion rackets, and gun and dope running in that country, was fairly openly involved in the last Punjab state elections. What followed were a spate of political murders and rankerous publicity campaigns that, many political pundits blame for skewing election results. Citizenship rights for NRIs would multiply such political troubles at all levels.
And, finally, Tharoor is upfront about his personal interest in the citizenship scheme for NRIs. He writes about the “anguish” his US-based sons “went through in being obliged to relinquish their Indian passports.” Most Indian ministers, senior government officials, and even military officers are not so open. “Diaspora Indians”, Tharoor writes, “are no less Indian in their hearts or in their sense of commitment to India.” Who knows what’s in the hearts of men and, in any case, that and the “sense of commitment”, etc. at best mean nothing, at worst are Trojan Horse threats in a milieu in which India is growingly vulnerable to external influences without its contriving to add to the sources that a variety of still bigger troubles can emanate from.


























































